Everytime by Britney Spears is featured in Britney 2.0, the second episode of Season Four. It is sung by Marley.
Marley asks Will if she can sing her favourite Britney Spears song to close Britney week. As she sings, Jake watches her with an upset expression - as he knows that Marley is singing this due to being unhappy with the fact that he is dating Kitty. During the performance, we see Rachel at NYADA, being watched by Brody, Brittany looking at her laptop screen, searching for Santana, Marley watching Jake serenade Kitty on the football field and finally, Rachel in her and Kurt's apartment, painting over Finn's name as the episode ends.
Lyrics
Marley:
Notice me
Take my hand
Why are we
Strangers when
Our love is strong
Why carry on without me?
Everytime I try to fly
I fall without my wings
I feel so small
I guess I need you baby
And everytime I see you in my dreams
I see your face, it's haunting me
I guess I need you baby
I make believe
That you are here
It's the only way
I see clear
What have I done
You seem to move on easy
And everytime I try to fly
I fall without my wings
I feel so small
I guess I need you baby
And everytime I see you in my dreams
I see your face, you're haunting me
I guess I need you baby
I may have made it rain
Please forgive me
My weakness caused you pain
And this song is my sorry
Ohhhh
At night I pray
That soon your face
Will fade away
And everytime I try to fly
I fall without my wings
I feel so small
I guess I need you baby
And everytime I see you in my dreams
I see your face, you're haunting me
I guess I need you baby