|Intimacy Level:|| Good Friends|
The rivalry began when Kitty and other members of the football team made fun of Marley and her mother, Millie Rose, in the cafeteria. This rivalry continues when Kitty dates Jake Puckerman, whom Marley also has a crush on. When Jake and Kitty break up, Kitty blames Marley, which is believed to be the foundation of her bitterness towards her. When McKinley decides to do Grease as their school musical both of them compete for the role of Sandy Olson, with Marley receiving the role; much to Kitty's jealously. Kitty then "befriends" Marley, manipulating her to believe that she is fat, which then culminates to Marley becoming bulimic. In Shooting Star, the eighteenth episode of Season Four, and after the traumatic shooting scare, Kitty confesses her actions to Marley and apologizes, which makes their bond grow stronger. While Kitty still makes fun of her on a daily basis, they now remain close friends.
During the whole episode, Kitty is seen, making fun of the new lunch lady, who is actually Marley's mom. Marley looks mad and hurt because of this. Kitty later tells the Glee Club that she agreed to be friends with the Glee kids and sit with them at lunch because of them winning National Championship, but she did not agree to hang out with Mike & Molly's daughter, after this she and two jocks slushie Marley and Unique.
Marley has a crush on Jake, who later in the episode asks her out and at the end of the performance of Crazy/U Drive Me Crazy, he gives Marley his jacket. In the hallway, Kitty hears a conversation between the two, in which Jake tells Marley his jacket looks good on her, Kitty interferes and tells them that it would look even better on her, stating that she and Jake are dating now. Marley then gives the jacket to Kitty, saying that they make a great couple hiding the fact that she's hurt. During her solo, Everytime, she watches Jake serenading Kitty in sadness.
Kitty invites Marley to the Left Behind Club stating that the end of time is coming. At the meeting at Breadstix, Kitty claims that the true believers will be lifted body and soul to heaven leaving the rest to duke it out. To state her point, she stages a fake rapture traumatizing Dottie Kazatori. Marley tells Jake that she really doesn't like that Kitty girl and that she can't believe that he does.
Later, Kitty interrupts Marley and Jake talking, first by asking if she is coveting her man, then taking jabs at her mother. When Jake tells Kitty to stop, he threatens to break off their relationship. Kitty warns him that she's like a bad Carrie Underwood song, but even despite that he breaks up with Kitty. Soon after, she blames Marley and then shoves a student in the hallway.
Kitty first spots Jake being jealous of Ryder as he talks to Marley. She then walks to the two of them, as she introduces herself, then rubs into Marley's face that she will be also auditioning for Sandy. Then, she tells Ryder that Marley will become overweight, and then says that Marley is the reason she and Jake broke up. She also says that she sees that Marley is pretending to be the innocent nice girl, but really is a scheming little kiss-ass. Marley then walks away upset.
Kitty auditions for the musical with Jake performing Everybody Talks. Marley watches both of them off stage, appearing jealous of the two.
When the cast list for the WMHS Production of Grease goes up, Marley receives the role of Sandy Olson, whereas Kitty receives the role of Patty Simcox. Kitty then shoves herself into Marley, and makes jabs about her weight saying that the stage will make her appear overweight, so she better find something slimming.
Kitty insists that Marley's inheriting her mother's weight problems, when her Sandy costume doesn't fit - but Kitty had secretly altered the costume beforehand. Claiming a desire to win new friends, Kitty invites the girls to a sleepover.
At the sleepover, Kitty mercilessly trots out donuts, and seeing Marley's panic, she takes her aside and not-so-subtly suggests that Marley should try a binging-and-purging approach. As Marley considers it in the bathroom, Kitty mocks her to the other girls with the Look At Me I'm Sandra Dee routine from Grease. Marley sees this and asks if Kitty is making fun of her.
Before the show begins, Marley rushes to Tina saying that her costume doesn't fit. Kitty who overhears, assures her she can get those inches off her before curtain call by throwing up.
Later, when the final performance is due, Kitty informs both Marley and Ryder that Fletcher Mantini, a merciless theater critic, is in the audience. This information shakes Marley's confidence.
After Kitty has joined New Directions, Finn gives her and Marley the assignment to perform a dynamic duet together, believing that they don't get along. Without consulting Marley on a song choice, Kitty hands her a lyrics sheet in the hallway. She also explained that she was going to dress as Femme Fatale, which meant "kill women" in French. Marley gets a little uneasy about this before leaving her locker.In another scene, Marley goes to Kitty's locker and says she can't do the duet with her, due to her wearing a spandex costume. Kitty questions her about her puking situation, and Marley says she's been doing it every day that week. Kitty then proposes that she'll call off the duet if she thought Marley was actually fat in the costume. They agree, the scene ending with Kitty showing off a conniving smile. In the bathroom, Kitty dresses into a one-piece catsuit, admiring her figure. Marley comes out with a costume her mother made for her, and explained that the WF on it meant "wall flower." Kitty tells her otherwise, and says she looks hot and promises to buy her new clothes. She even changes her superhero name from Wall Flower to Woman Fierce, confident that she and Marley will kill their number. The scene then continues in the choir room, where the two perform Holding Out for a Hero by Bonnie Tyler in front of New Directions.
Kitty approaches Marley after Ryder calls off their outing for Friday night, due to seeing the special education specialist. Kitty assumes that Ryder isn't into Marley, and insists on her trying to continue with the two-fingers suggestion. Marley denies it, saying that the old her would stay home on a Friday night and that won't happen any longer. She walks towards Jake, asking him what he was planning on doing for Friday night. He responds with "Going on a date with you," which Marley confirms and walks away proudly. This leaves Kitty staring at her, shocked.
At the end of the episode, they perform Some Nights with the rest of New Directions. They start off friendly, but Kitty rolls her eyes without anyone's notice.
Kitty reveals intense worship of Quinn, who notices that Marley seems under pressure. Kitty assures her she's been trying to help Marley, and she leads Quinn to believe that Marley's distraction stems from another case of a good girl dating a Puckerman - something Quinn knows all too well.
Santana tells Quinn she believes Kitty is "pure evil" and responsible for giving Marley laxatives.
Marley and Kitty then later on perform Gangnam Style together with the New Directions, during which Marley faints due to her eating disorder.
In a deleted scene, Marley finds Kitty crying in the bathroom because of New Directions' loss at Sectionals, though she claims it is because she has allergies. Kitty admits that she has been awful to Marley and is confused as to why Marley is still being nice to her; Marley responds that she thinks that Kitty's meanness is just because she's scared.
Marley then invites Kitty to come and discuss song choices for their last performance, but Kitty sharply rebuffs her. However, she then calls Marley back and, in a friendlier tone, thanks her for asking.
To thank Sue for her generous gift for her and her mom, Marley gets most of the members of New Directions, including Kitty, to help her out to sing Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas on the auditorium stage.
At the end of the episode, she and Kitty share a group hug with Ryder and Joe.
In the episode, Sadie Hawkins, they do not interact, but Kitty mentions her in a rough, unfriendly way. At first, when Finn announces the "Ladie's Choice" assignment, for the girls to choose a song to sing to invite the boys to the dance, Kitty comes in saying that she knows who she'll be inviting, to which she looks at Jake and Marley gives an uncomfortable look.
Before Tell Him, Marley explains that Jake has been acting weird after Marley collapsed at Sectionals, and has moved away and once again, at Kitty's tail. At the end of the performance, Marley asks Jake to the dance, to which he gives an optimistic 'yes', but this makes Kitty look upset.
When Jake gets into school, Kitty clicks her fingers and makes sure the Cheerios lock the doors tight. She says that he should dump the "bulimic" girl, and go with her instead because Kitty knows Jake has needs and Marley wouldn't do it. Jake seems confused as he thought they were friends.
At the Lima Bean, Jake discusses this with his brother, Puck, to which Jake says that Kitty keeps going all over him, while he likes Marley.Diamonds Are A Girl's Best Friend/Material Girl, Kitty comes up to Marley and apologizes for everything bad that she's said/done to Marley. And while saying that she mentions the Puckerbros, and Marley suddenly looks away. Kitty sees it and asks Marley what's wrong. Marley wants to say something to her, but asks her to swear that she woudn't tell anyone. Kitty swears, but she has her fingers crossed behind her back. Marley tells Kitty that Ryder kissed her and that's she still likes Jake, but she doesn't get to finish the sentence, because Kitty interrupts her by saying that she completely gets it and says to Marley that she's not a slut, and since they are now BFFs (in Kitty's words), she gives her some advice and that is that Marley should collect as many boys as she can. Then Kitty walks away and Marley looks conflicted.
In this episode, Kitty states that they are friends, when they all agree on walking Unique home after school.
Kitty comments on Marley, saying that she should be Posh spice, because she's skinny and makes everyone uncomfortable. Kitty also helps Marley and the New Directions Girls as they lecture Jake about his song choice for the Guilty Pleasures assignment, being the artist Chris Brown, to which they oppose. Later Kitty and Marley perform together with the girls Wannabe. They also dance and sing together during Mamma Mia.
In this episode, when the shooting happens, Kitty and Marley sit next to each other to hide from the chaos, and when Marley tries to call her mom and she doesn't answer, she worries, while Kitty replies, "no one's going to hurt your mom, everyone likes her," and then Kitty gets emotional and apologizes to Marley for trying to tamper with her dresses during Grease to make her look fat. They hug, but Kitty crawls away from her and to Ryder and Unique's hiding spot. At the end of the episode they are seen hugging.
When Blaine calls a private meeting with New Directions in the auditorium, Marley expresses her idea of performing one of her original songs for Regionals to everyone. She is then shot down by Kitty, who disagrees and says that she doesn't want to sing about "a fat mother or a song about barfing, or a song about loving an octoroon." During Marley's original song, Outcast, Kitty runs onto the stage during the chorus and hugs Marley, as they spin.
During Jake's solo, I Wish, to which he dances with Mike, Marley says "You nasty boy!" in a seductive way. Kitty and a few others give a shocked expression.
In this episode, Ryder is tired of the catfisher and wants to know who it is. When Marley covers up for the real catfisher, Unique, Kitty is one of the many in the room to seem both confused and shocked.
Kitty and Artie secrety start dating. Tina exposes their relationship and says that Artie deserves to be loved openly. Kitty than says she wanted to be sure that she truely loves Artie, after Marley asked her "[Sure] Of what?" When Kitty and Artie start official dating, Marley can be seen smiling and happy for them.Sam. Later in the McKinley High Non-Denominational Christmas Club Marley expresses her wish to play the role of Virgin Mary in the living nativity. When Kitty shoots her down with a rude comment, she replies "Yeah, well... You wear a smaller bra than me." Kitty seems shocked Marley brought that up. Later Marley approaches Kitty in the hallway and tells her about the idea of all the New Directions Girls auditioning together for the part of Mary. After Kitty insults the girls and says she could easily get the part, but doesn't want it, Marley seems confused. They both sing Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree while decorating the Christmas tree with the rest of New Directions. Kitty watches Marley's audition for the part of Virgin Mary, and doesn't seem happy at the end. They are seen sitting together in the History class when Sue announces the winners of the Christmas tree decorating contest.
Kitty ruins Marley's happiness over being cast as Mary by insulting her. Marley realizes that role means a lot to Kitty and offers to talk to Mr Schue and let Kitty get the role. Kitty turns it down saying she doesn't deserve to be Mary because she doesn't have the Virgin Mary spirit in her heart. That prompts Marley to discuss it with other Glee Club members, who then figure out a way to make Kitty accept the role, in hopes of her being nicer to them after that. At the rehearsal Kitty asks Marley why she isn't dressed as Mary, and Marley informs her that there has been a change of plans. Kitty watches Marley performing Love Child, with Unique playing Mary, with disgust, and after the performance demands that she gets the role. At the end of the episode, when Kitty joins the rest of New Directions at the living nativity, Marley tells her she looks beautiful as Virgin Mary.
Sang Together (In a Group Number)
|Some Nights||Dynamic Duets||Blaine, Jake, Ryder, Sam, Tina, and Joe|
|Wannabe||Guilty Pleasures||Unique, Tina, and Brittany|
|Mamma Mia||Rachel, Santana, Kurt, Sam, Blaine, and Unique|
|Say||Shooting Star||Blaine, Ryder, Brittany, and Sam|
|Outcast||Sweet Dreams||Jake, Unique, Kitty, and Ryder|
|Longest Time||Lights Out||Artie, Jake, Ryder, and Sam|
|On Our Way||The End of Twerk||Tina, Artie, Sam, Blaine, Jake, Ryder, and Unique|
|Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree||Previously Unaired Christmas||Will, Artie and Jake|
- Everybody Talks by Neon Trees. (The Role You Were Born to Play)
- Look At Me I'm Sandra Dee from Grease. (Glease)
- Gangnam Style by PSY. (Thanksgiving)
- Diamonds Are a Girl's Best Friend/Material Girl by Marilyn Monroe/Madonna. (Girls (and Boys) on Film)
- Love Child by The Supremes. (Previously Unaired Christmas)
- Both have dated Jake Puckerman.
- Both have had romantic interests for Ryder Lynn.
- A deleted scene from Swan Song about their friendship can be watched here.
|Character relationship(s) displayed: