Rachel (Finn):
When you first left me,
I was wanting more
You were kissing that girl next door
What you do that for? (What you do that for?)

When you first left me

Rachel & Finn,
I didn't know what to say,
I never been on my own that way,
Just sat by myself all day

Rachel:
I was so lost back then,
But with a little help from my friends,
I found a light in the tunnel at the end

Now you're calling me up on the phone,
So you can have a little whine and a moan,
And its only because you're feeling alone

Rachel & Finn:
At first, when I see you cry,

Yeah it makes me smile,

Yeah makes me smile
At worst, I feel bad for awhile,

But then I just smile, I go ahead and smile

Rachel (Finn):
Whenever you see me,
You say that you want me back,
But I tell you it don't mean jack, (don't mean jack)
No it don't mean jack, (it don't mean jack)

Rachel & Finn:
I couldn't stop laughing,
No I just couldn't help myself,
See, you messed up my mental health,
I was quite unwell

Rachel:
I was so lost back then,
But with a little help from my friends,
I found a light in the tunnel at the end
Now you're calling me up on the phone,
So you can have a little whine and a moan,
And its only 'cause you're feeling alone

Rachel & Finn:
At first,
When I see you cry,
Yeah it makes me smile,
Yeah makes me smile
At worst, I feel bad for awhile, but then i just smile,
I go ahead and smile

At first,
When I see you cry,
Yeah it makes me smile,
Yeah makes me smile
At worst, I feel bad for awhile,
But then I just smile, I go ahead and smile

At first,
When I see you cry,
Yeah it makes me smile,
Yeah makes me smile.
At worst,
I feel bad for a while,
but then I just smile,
I go ahead and smile