Kurt asked Dave how his life is going at his new school. David says he's enjoying it because he can finish high school and play football, without worrying about his teammates spreading rumors about his sexuality.
Dave meets Kurt Hummel at Breadstix to reveal that he is Kurt's secret admirer, but soon discovers that one of his new football teammates, Nick is also there with his girlfriend for Valentine's Day and heard their conversation.
After the events of Heart, Karofsky finds that his locker room locker has the word "fag" written across it in pink spray paint. It is evident that Nick told the rest of the football team what he overheard at Breadstix. The entire football team mocks David and then continues the bullying through Facebook which drives him to later attempt suicide. While at the hospital, Dave tells Kurt that he's not going back to Thurston.